Which planet's removal causes less drastic repercussions for Earth's safety profile compared to Jupiter's?
Answer
Saturn
While the removal of any major planet would induce shifts, Jupiter's removal has the most severe consequences specifically for the inner solar system stability and Earth. When compared to Saturn, Jupiter's sheer magnitude grants it an unmatched dominance over the inner system's safety profile. Removing Saturn would certainly destabilize the outer system and alter comet distribution, but Jupiter's superior mass and critical positioning relative to the asteroid belt and the orbits of Mars and Earth mean its contribution to keeping our local corner quiet is by far the largest portion of the required stability overhead.
#Videos
What If Jupiter Never Existed? - YouTube
What If Jupiter Never Existed? - YouTube
Related Questions
How much more massive is Jupiter than all other planets combined?What is Jupiter's primary role described as when dealing with hazardous debris?What long-term orbital scenario might Earth face without Jupiter's gravitational guidance?What potentially catastrophic fate could Mercury face if Jupiter were removed?What is Jupiter largely responsible for creating regarding the Asteroid Belt configuration?What effect do Jupiter's strong resonances act as, concerning Mars and Earth's orbital periods?If Jupiter were removed, what change would occur to the objects in the Asteroid Belt?What concept does Jupiter's mass subtly affect the center of mass of the entire solar system around?What allows complex life on Earth to evolve, according to hypotheses about Jupiter's protective work?Which planet's removal causes less drastic repercussions for Earth's safety profile compared to Jupiter's?