What distinguishes the fate of a stage that executes a splashdown versus one that successfully lands on a drone ship?
Answer
It cannot typically be recovered for immediate refurbishment due to corrosive damage and impact stress
Hardware that settles on the seabed after an uncontrolled splashdown faces severe challenges from salt water and impact forces, preventing reuse, whereas hardware landing upright on a barge is the economic justification for recovery.

#Videos
Why SpaceX Really Lands In The Ocean (Physics) - YouTube
Related Questions
What factor primarily determines the destination—a concrete pad or a drone ship—for a returning rocket stage?What is the main reason rockets launching eastward from coastal sites often land downrange over the Atlantic Ocean?What trade-off must be accepted to maximize the payload mass delivered to a high orbit?What function do specialized, unmanned marine platforms serve in modern rocketry?In rocketry, what specifically defines a 'splashdown'?What is a significant logistical advantage of recovering a booster on a fixed concrete pad like LZ-1?Why might a reusable booster be unable to land on a land pad even if it has sufficient range to reach the launch site?How does the geography of a launch site influence early stage separation safety?What distinguishes the fate of a stage that executes a splashdown versus one that successfully lands on a drone ship?What sequence of burns must a first stage perform to return successfully for reuse?When a mission can afford the fuel margin, which recovery site is generally preferred logistically?